Print version of

Journal Contents

all articles of volume 4 issue 4 | return to Journal Contents

Article of Volume 4, Issue 4, December 2009

Contrasting the use of tools for presentation and critique: Some cases from architectural education

Authors: Gustav Lymer, Jonas Ivarsson, Oskar Lindwall

Abstract: This study investigates video recordings of design reviews in architectural education, focusing on how presentations and discussions of designs are contingent on the specific tools employed. In the analyzed recordings, three different setups are utilized: traditional posters, digital slide-show technologies, and combinations of the two. This range of different setups provides a set of contrasts that make visible the role of technologies in shaping the ways in which the reviews are conducted. The analysis is structured in three themes. First, we examine the sequential organization of digital presentations in relation to the spatial structure of poster-based presentations. Second, the different ways in which shared attention is established in digital, paper-based, and hybrid presentation practices are analyzed. Third, we address part-whole relations—how details in presented materials are put in relation to the overarching project or the presentation as a whole. Taken together, the analyses suggest that the detailed organization of the design review is transformed in subtle yet consequential ways through the introduction of digital slide-show technologies. These transformations are consequential not only locally, for the design review itself, but also for the instructive work that is accomplished through this practice. We conclude by discussing some implications for design, arguing that an increased awareness of how the practice is influenced by the different setups might be key for the proper adaptation of presentation technologies to particular purposes.

Keywords: Architectural education, Design reviews, Ethnomethodology, Video analysis, Presentation practice and technology

Citation: Lymer, G., Ivarsson, J., & Lindwall, O. (2009) Contrasting the use of tools for presentation and critique: Some cases from architectural education. ijcscl 4 (4), pp. 423-444

DOI: 10.1007/s11412-009-9073-9

Preprint: Acrobat-PDF lymer_ivarsson_lindwall_4_4.pdf

About this article at [] including a link to the official electronic version.